I took a step back yesterday - in a good way. This post may sound hypocritical... and if it does, well just deal with it.
Yesterday morning, 4/29/2010, I woke up fully aware that my spouse's current TMobile contract for which she has a clamshell just expired and that we'd have to eventually get her another phone and plan. I was also fully aware that Verizon, my favorite carrier out of the two I've had (AT&T being the other), was releasing the HTC Incredible on this day which is the latest and greatest Android based phone.
I have an iPhone. I bought it last year when my Verizon plan was done and Verizon had no hope of delivering a smartphone that was worth a damn in my eyes - obviously well before the Droid came out.
I like my iPhone.
I also am annoyed a small bit by certain things on the iPhone. One of the many small annoyances is that one of the apps I use frequently, Food Scanner, actually turns off my music player to operate. Talk about lack of multitasking! It did this to me while I was scanning the label of my turkey sausage and oatmeal during breakfast. "Man, I wouldn't have this problem on Android, would I", I thought to myself.
Right there, I decided I was going to go check out the Incredible that day as my potentially future phone with plans to give my spouse the iPhone 3GS as a hand-me-down.
I arrive at the pretty much empty Verizon store that afternoon and started having the sales rep show me the floor model of the Incredible. I was actually a bit underwhelmed but not for the reasons you think. I was underwhelmed by its complexity. The entire time I was using I was thinking to myself "am I in the market for a phone or a minature laptop". The reality of it all is that I was in the market for a phone, and the Incredible was just incredibly too much for that purpose. The iPhone, in my view, is basically a PDA with internet / phone capability. The Incredible felt like someone trying to shove a laptop in to a form factor that actually seemed smaller/lighter than the iPhone.
That's a great thing actually! But it's not great for me. I like minimalism. There's too much emphasis on what our phones ought to do for us. I just want a phone + pda that can entertain me now and then and give me a convergence of all of the little gadgets that I might want to carry around in my pocket. What I don't want is something that has the look and feel of a laptop to me - and that's what the Droid OS on the Incredible felt like. Further, I'm happy with what I have right now. - my current phone suits my needs and there's no need to go chase the next big thing.